Several groups connected to the community (the Liberty Coalition, eCitizen Foundation, CDT, and others) are concerned that no meaningful public discussion has occurred.

The eCitizen Foundation will sponsor a phone call tomorrow, July 13^th at 3:00pm Eastern to encourage discussion about the NSTIC.The purpose of the phone call is not to gain consensus, except on one issue: The NSTIC needs more public discussion and analysis.

Call 202-684-7800 then press 9 then 801.

NSTIC: http://www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/ns_tic.pdf.

Public Comments: http://www.nstic.ideascale.com/

NSTIC Discussion: http://www.nstic.us – on line viagra

1; levitra online.User Control and Consent:

Digital identity systems must only reveal information identifying a user with the user’s consent. (Starts here…)

2.Limited Disclosure for Limited Use

The solution which discloses the least identifying information and best limits its use is the most stable levitra online, long-term solutio.(Starts here…)

The Law of Fewest Parties

Digital identity systems must limit disclosure of identifying information to parties having a necessary and justifiable place in a given identity relationship.(Starts here…)

4 – levitra online.Directed Identity

A universal identity metasystem must support both “omnidirectional” identifiers for use by public entities and “unidirectional” identifiers for private entities, thus facilitating discovery while preventing unnecessary release of correlation handles. (Starts here…)

5 – levitra online.Pluralism of Operators and Technologies:

A universal identity metasystem must channel and enable the interworking of multiple identity technologies run by multiple identity providers. (Starts here…)

6.Human Integration:

A unifying identity metasystem must define the human user as a component integrated through protected and unambiguous human-machine communications. (Starts here…)

7; levitra online.Consistent Experience Across Contexts:

A unifying identity metasystem must provide a simple consistent experience while enabling separation of contexts through multiple operators and technologies. (Starts here…)

The user-centric / user-driven identity community formed around the time that blogging was becoming common. Levitra online: doc Searls a very early blogger was also a community thought leader and encouraged many members of  “the gang” to start their own blogs – to dialogue with each other and to share their ideas with each other and a wider world then a community mailing list provided.

One of the key bloggers inspired at the time by Doc was Kim Cameron the chief Identity Architect at Microsoft.He came to Microsoft from a small company he founded ZoomIT where he invented metadirectory technology.

Identity of people in the physical and digital world is complex and has many different tensions that need to be balanced.  Levitra online: he developed the Laws of Identity to articulate fundamental ideas/principles that need to be obeyed.  Levitra online: here is how he explains this work:

I have undertaken a project to develop a formal understanding of the dynamics causing digital identity systems to succeed or fail in various contexts, expressed as the Laws of Identity. Levitra online: taken together, these laws define a unifying identity metasystem that can offer the Internet the identity layer it so obviously requires.  They also provide a way for people new to the identity discussion to understand its central issues.  This lets them actively join in, rather than everyone having to restart the whole discussion from scratch.

Those of us who work on or with identity systems need to obey the Laws of Identity.  Otherwise, we create a wake of reinforcing side-effects that eventually undermine all resulting technology.  The result is similar to what would happen if civil engineers were to flaunt the law of gravity.By following them we can build a unifying identity metasystem that is widely accepted and enduring.

Kim posted the laws one by one in the Winter of 2005 and generated a lot of interest and anticipation in doing so; levitra online.  Levitra online: the community responded and shared their own ideas about the laws as they were published.  Levitra online: all of this feedback was taken and incorporated into what became the final document and he acknowledges them in this way.

The ideas presented here were refined here in the Blogosphere in a wide-ranging conversation that crossed many of the conventional faultlines of the computer industry, as well as in various private communications. Levitra online: in particular I would like to thank Arun Nanda, Andre Durand, Bill Barnes, Carl Ellison, Caspar Bowden, Craig Burton, Dan Blum, Dave Kearns, Dave Winer, Dick Hardt, Doc Searls, Drummond Reed, Ellen McDermott, Eric Norlin, Esther Dyson, Fen Labalme, Identity Woman Kaliya, JC Cannon, James Kobielus, James Governor, Jamie Lewis, John Shewchuk, Luke Razzell, Marc Canter, Mark Wahl, Martin Taylor, Mike Jones, Phil Becker, Radovan Janocek, Ravi Pandya, Robert Scoble, Scott C.Lemon, Simon Davies, Stefan Brands, Stuart Kwan and William Heath.

Here are the updates from community groups from our April 7th meeting.

• Project VRM
  • Emancipay app accepted for public radio contributions
  • VRM meeting in London this week – Doc is there

• OSIS
  • Participated at RSA and was the “organizer” of the official OASIS interop
  • Next interop is planned for Catalyst but it is not announced yet.

• OpenID
  • Rescope of mission to be more inclusive of a solutions approach and structural change.
  • Started work on what will become OpenID vNext, and officially formed several work groups in the OpenID Foundation.The results are all up on the wiki and all the presentations.

• User-centric Health
  • Has been quiet – buy viagra online. Buy viagra online: mike has personally been participating in several other group efforts: California HIE and recently in two Kantara initiatives, WGA identity assurance framework and the group Joe runs.User centric heath conjurs-up the idea of a user channeling how to get information.Have been focusing on participating in a couple of the federal groups – buy viagra online.The two biggest things are the end to end direct and interop between states and entities.Judy Clark made some of us aware of it.I’m working on use cases nhindirect.org – buy viagra online.Brian Belendorf; buy viagra online.is one of the leaders of that group.
  • Buy viagra online: there will be a Health Camp on October 6th

• Privacy Commons – not an official IC working group Aaron has joined calls for several months and was invited to share what his group is up to
  • The group aiming to launch new version of website in a month or two.Whole idea is make privacy policy’s more useful – buy viagra online.Current approach is either corporate or data centric; buy viagra online.Both assume that data is property of a sort.We want to analyze privacy policies from a user centric perspective.Data equals self.Privacy policy talks about discrete data, but people care about core privacy values; buy viagra online.If self is data and data is property, then self may become property – buy viagra online.We are asking “What do people care about privacy?” It is like copyright work done at Creative Commons; buy viagra online. Buy viagra online: these deal with violations of confidentiality, trust, etc.For example buy viagra online, based on my interactions with you, what determinations will others make that may effect my reputation or solitude, etc.We are identifying common cultural notions about what people care about privacy.

• Information Card Foundation
  • About half of Drummond’s energy is being contributed to OIX – buy viagra online.He has been working with Ely Kahn, the White House Cyber security director on the National strategy for Secure Online transactions (NS-SOT); buy viagra online.It was on federal radio on Monday; buy viagra online.A new national trust framework is being announced in the Sep timeframe with Obama signing it – buy viagra online.The other thing is the interop – buy viagra online.Mary already talked about that.

• Data Portability
  • Elias did the Startup Bus where people get on a Bus and in 800 miles design, build and launch a startup.He said that they had to be a part of this create a portability pledge and that they used what is being finalized – portabilitypolicy.org that is 9 questions startups answer

• Higgins Project
  • Client Software for unix buy viagra online, apple, windows, iPhone and Android
  • Working on Blind Store for Personal Data Store where only people have the key

• Internet Identity Workshop
  • IIW is May 17-19.We are starting at 9:00 AM on Monday morning.We will do 5 sessions a day for 3 says – buy viagra online.There are15 sessions in total.We will have dinner Monday and Tuesday night as per usual – buy viagra online. Buy viagra online: there is only one hour of introductory talk.I wanted to get your thoughts on how to be comprehensive without over whelming.I want to talk about this next.Also there will be demos for an hour after lunch – buy viagra online.On Wednesday we will probably end at 4:00.Not sure when we will end.Currently the agenda says 5:00.

– buy viagra online

It will be a great opportunity to connect with the people who go to the Internet Identity Workshop coming up May 17-19 in Mountain View.

The workshop attracts industry leaders for 3 full days of intense interactive discussions – online viagra. We will have 5 working sessions per-day; online viagra. The agenda is created live the day of the event.On our home page you can find the notes from the last three IIW’s along with a list of attendees for each. For the upcoming workshop a list of proposed topics is developing on the wiki; online viagra.

This first appeared as a triangle in one of Johannes’ introductory talks at IIW in 2006.

The Liberty identity pillar – order viagra.This pillar is ready-made for corporate adoption: identity is “given” to the individual by the corporation (e.g.the employer), and it is the corporation that decides which identity attributes are managed and shared with whom.Even if the corporation gives the individual many choices, it is ultimately the corporation who decides whether or not to give those choices to the individual; order viagra.Typically order viagra, Liberty implementation projects are between companies; the individual does not participate directly.

The WS-*-based identity pillar, which, at this juncture, is largely driven by Microsoft.InfoCards is a new “Identity Selector” application that will be bundled, we are told, with every copy of Windows Vista when it ships.It is based on a number of WS-* standards, some WS-* specifications that are expected to become standards at some point, and some Microsoft extensions.As Vista has not shipped yet, there are still many open questions, such as whether it will ever be seriously supported on non-Microsoft operating systems or non-PC devices, or how it could interoperate with non-WS-* based architectures and protocols.

The URL-based identity pillar, which is largely an open-source, grassroots effort; order viagra.It aims to put the individual fully in control: over identity providers, over attributes, over whether or not to have an identity or how many, over which software to run from which vendor, and over the feature set associated with their identity.Its most visible sign is the use of URLs to point to people, just like we use URLs to point to companies or documents – order viagra. Order viagra: this pillar is rapidly coming together in the YADIS community, which essentially facilitates an open marketplace of interoperable identity-related features from which the individual may pick as many or as few as they like.

A year later it evolved….

The big differences to the January version are the following:

• The various URL-based technologies (LID, i-names, Yadis, Sxip, XRI, et al) have come together under the OpenID term.
• Microsoft gets a lot of credit for their support of the OSIS project, which brings together most important enterprise software vendors and a number of startups, and thus makes this third column far less Microsoft-controlled than it appeared in January.
• There are various very encouraging signs that the OpenID and SAML/Liberty communities are coming together, allowing the use of SAML in a user-centric manner, which would allow all three columns in a user-centric manner.

This was done in a bit of hurry, so please tell me whether I’m wrong and bear with me if I update it a few times.

Paul Madsen did a sketch and Eve Maler did this electronic version that appeared in her RSA presentations.

The diagram became a Venn

She worked with Drummond on a paper published in the IEEE you can find here.

I highly recommend reading this to “get our industry”

By September 2009 she had refined it further.

It is licensed Creative commons with attribution.

This evolution of shared understanding is part of what it has meant to be a community together figuring out the complexities of supporting people’s identities online – order viagra.

This slideshow/PDF covers

• Modern Identity History
• Identities 3 Pillars (URL based, Card based and invisible)
• The basic User-Centric Flow
• Kim’s Laws of Identity
• Customer Trust
• A future pointing to project VRM

Enjoy!; buy viagra

It uses the internet archive and text to narrate how the web has evolved from static pages with links to people generated content

These are the lines it closes with.

Digital text is no longer just linking information…

The web is connecting people sharing, trading, collaborating

We need to rethink a few things… copyright, authorship, identity, ethics, asthetics, retorics, governance,  privacy, commerce, love, family, ourselves.

It is the space for this “rethinking” that Identity Commons is meant to support – online pharmacy viagra.It is not something that can be figured out by corporations for corporations it must be a wholistic dialogue inclusive of a range of perspectives including the most important actor – the people themselves the end-user.

– online pharmacy viagra

Here is the Lexicon that got developed on the identity gang list in 2005.

This was not meant to be used to talk with “regular people” but rather this community of specialists to talk about detailed specifics of identity systems.

Agent A computer system or device that has been delegated (authority buy cialis online, responsibility, a function, etc.) by and acts for a Party (in exercising the authority, carrying out the responsibility, performing the function, etc.).

Claim : An assertion made by a Claimant of the value or values of one or more Identity Attributes of a Digital Subject, typically an assertion which is disputed or in doubt.

Claimant: A Digital Subject representing a Party that makes a Claim

Digital Identity: A digital representation of a set of Claims made by one Party about itself or another Digital Subject.

Digital Identity Provider: An Agent that issues a Digital Identity.

Digital Subject: An Entity represented or existing in the digital realm which is being described or dealt with.

Entity: A person, physical object, animal, or juridical entity

Identity Attribute: A property of a Digital Subject that may have zero or more values.

Identity Context: The surrounding environment and circumstances that determine meaning of Digital Identities and the policies and protocols that govern their interactions.

Party: A natural person or a juridical entity.

Persona: A preexisting Digital Identity that a user through an Agent has the ability to select and use to represent themselves in a given Identity Context.

Relying Party: A Party that makes known through its Agent one or more alternative sets of Claims that it desires or requires, and receives through this same Agent a Digital Identity purportedly including the required Claims from a Digital Identity Provider or other Agent of another Party.

The second idea is a one-eyed smiley; cialis on line.As Meng Weng Wong, who conceived of this logo, explained:

In Book 9 of Homer’s Odyssey, a scouting party led by Odysseus lands on the Island of the Cyclopes and discovers a large cave; cialis on line.They enter into the cave and feast on food they find there; cialis on line.This cave is the home of Polyphemus cialis on line, who soon returns and traps the trespassers in the cave. Cialis on line: he proceeds to eat several crew members, but Odysseus devises a cunning plan for escape.

To make Polyphemus unwary, Odysseus gives him a skin of very strong, unwatered wine.When Polyphemus asks for Odysseus’ name, he tells him that it is ‘Outis’, Greek for ‘no man’ or ‘nobody’.Once the giant falls asleep drunk, Odysseus and his men take the spit from the fire and drive it through Polyphemus’ only eye; cialis on line.Polyphemus’ cries of help are answered by the others of his race; however, they turn away from aiding him when they hear that “Nobody” is the cause of his woes.

This being the first recorded case of a security breach due to the lack of an identity management infrastructure, I hope that the Gentle Reader will forgive me for the visual pun: your upside-down umbrella is also a one-i’ed smiley.

As would be expected, this logo emerged from the efforts of several members of our community.Paul Trevithick drove the process and engaged with the designer to produce several iterations. Cialis on line: kaliya Hamlin suggested basing the logo around the upside-down umbrella metaphor.Meng Weng Wong built off of Kaliya’s idea and introduced the Cyclops metaphor – cialis on line.